Solar Shingles vs. Solar Panels: Which Is the Better Choice for Your Home?

When it comes to powering your home with clean, renewable energy, you might be wondering about solar shingles vs. solar panels:  which is the better choice?  Both options can help you harness the sun’s energy and reduce your reliance on traditional electricity sources, but they each have their own unique benefits and drawbacks. 

When it comes to generating electricity for your home, solar shingles and solar panels have some similar features.  But, there are also some notable differences that can make one more suitable for your unique situation. Your budget, the state of your roof, and your personal style are all important considerations to keep in mind as you weigh the pros and cons of solar shingles vs. solar panels. 

In this post, we’ll take a closer look at how solar shingles and solar panels compare in terms of cost, efficiency, durability, and more.  By the end, you’ll have a better understanding of which option might be the right choice for your home as you consider solar shingles vs. solar panels.

Solar Shingles vs. Solar Panels: Which Is the Better Choice?

Choosing between solar shingles and solar panels can be a bit overwhelming, especially if you’re new to harnessing solar energy for your home. Both options have their pros and cons, and the right choice for you will depend on your specific needs and goals.

Pros and Cons of Solar Shingles

The concept of solar shingles is changing the game.  While they’re undoubtedly low-profile, generating clean energy as part of your roofing setup sounds like a remarkable fusion of function and style.  Suddenly, reaching for that shiny new aspect feels quite fetching, a result rather than a means to survive in an economically bright atmosphere.  

The downside? Solar shingles cost more upfront than traditional solar panels. But hey, you’re getting a new roof out of the deal. In the long run, it could be a smart investment.

Pros and Cons of Solar Panels

Solar panels have resisted the temptation of fading into obscurity, instead solidifying their reputation as a trusted solution. With an unblemished track record spanning decades, they’ve consistently delivered on their promise of reliability and efficiency. And as the cost of solar panels continues to decline, their appeal only grows stronger.

The catch? Solar panels can be a bit of an eyesore on your roof. Some homeowners associations even ban them for aesthetic reasons. But if looks aren’t a top priority, solar panels are a solid choice. You also need to make sure you have a professional install them. If they are installed incorrectly, they could cause leaks in your roof, making them less appealing.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Solar Shingles and Solar Panels

Ideally, homeowners contemplating solar energy installations should carefully consider their specific needs. For instance, if a sleek and modern appearance is paramount, solar shingles are worth exploring. However, solar panels offer greater efficiency and are often the better choice for larger homes or those with plenty of available space.

• Your budget.
• The age and condition of your roof.
• Your energy needs.
• Your local climate and sun exposure.
• Aesthetics and curb appeal.

In the market for solar energy for your home? Consider the advantages of solar shingles and solar panels. Both options offer the ability to harness renewable energy and reduce your carbon footprint. Getting quotes for both and weighing the pros and cons can help you make a confident decision.

What Are Solar Shingles and How Do They Work?

Raise your hand if you ever imagined your roof would act like a sponge, soaking up sunbeams and converting them into 120-volt electricity. Yeah, us neither. Or at least, we didn’t until solar shingles burst onto the scene. Like modern-day superheroes, these photovoltaic polymers, working behind the scenes, quietly generate power while maintaining an inconspicuous existence.

Components of Solar Shingles

Ranging from the clear coated panel that absorbs sunlight to the cleverly designed clips that secure the shingle to the roof, eah component is a vital piece of the puzzle that brings power to your home. 

• Photovoltaic cells to convert sunlight into electricity.
• Wiring to carry the electric current.
• Protective layers and coatings.
• Mounting hardware to secure the shingles to your roof.

Installation Process for Solar Shingles

Installing solar shingles is a bit more involved than slapping on traditional solar panels. The process typically includes:

1. Removing existing roof shingles.
2. Installing a waterproof underlayment.
3. Mounting the solar shingles.
4. Connecting the wiring and electrical components.

You wouldn’t hire an amputee mechanic to fix your car, right?  Think twice about assigning sensitive tasks like roofing and electrical work to those who lack the necessary expertise.  People whose hands haven’t grappled with tricky wiring or climbed roofs with a flashlight between their teeth just aren’t the right fit.  Take our word for it:  only permit experienced pros with a solid background in their specialties. 

Types of Roofs Suitable for Solar Shingles

Solar shingles work best on sloped roofs with standard roofing materials like asphalt or composite shingles. If you’ve got a flat roof, metal roof, or tile roof, solar shingles might not be the best fit.

What Are Solar Panels and How Do They Work?

Solar panels have undergone significant transformations since their inception in the 1950s. Witnessing rapid progress in efficiency, performance, and affordability, they’ve taken their rightful place as a viable, environmentally conscious alternative to traditional energy sources.

Components of Solar Panels

The average solar panel is composed of cunningly designed parts, whose synergy generates a remarkable performance. Beginning with the photovoltaic cell itself, where photons prompt electrons to tumble about, setting in motion a sequence of events that culminates in electrical energy.

• Photovoltaic cells, usually made of silicon, that absorb sunlight and generate electricity.
• A metal frame for mounting.
• Wiring to carry the electric current.
• A glass cover to protect the cells.

Installation Process for Solar Panels

Conquering the sun is a realistic goal when it comes to solar panel installation. By following a few simple steps and utilizing readily available materials, even the greenest thumb can reap the benefits of renewable energy.

1. Mounting brackets are attached to your roof.
2. The solar panels are secured to the brackets.
3. Wiring is connected to an inverter and your home’s electrical system.

Most installations can be completed in a day or two by a professional solar installer.

Types of Roofs Suitable for Solar Panels

The roofs we live under are just the beginning of where solar panels can thrive.  The ability to be installed on various types of roofs, including asphalt shingle, tile, metal, and more, the versatility of solar panels opens doors to a more sustainable future. 

• Asphalt shingles.
• Metal.
• Tile.
• Flat roofs.

As long as your roof is in good condition and gets plenty of maximum sun exposure, solar panels are a viable option.

Cost Comparison: Solar Shingles vs. Solar Panels

Let’s talk numbers. The cost of solar shingles and solar panels can vary widely depending on factors like the size of your roof, your location, and the specific products you choose.

Factors Affecting Solar Shingle Costs

Solar shingles are generally more expensive than solar panels, with prices ranging from $15 to $20 per square foot installed. For a typical roof, that can add up to $30,000 or more.

The premium price tag for solar shingles comes from the advanced technology involved, which requires specialized installation. To top it off, you’re essentially getting a brand-new roof and a solar system combo package. Campo Roof can provide a FREE estimate and let you know if you’d be a good candidate for solar shingles here.

Factors Affecting Solar Panel Costs

Solar panels are more affordable, with an average cost of $3 to $5 per watt.  For a typical 6 kilowatt system, that works out to $18,000 to $30,000 before incentives. Solar panel pricing has undergone a remarkable decline due to steady progress in tech and an intensified market. 

Long-term Cost Savings

If you opt for solar energy, you’ll not only enjoy substantial savings on electricity bills over the next quarter-century but also capitalize on tax credits and incentives to defray the initial investment. Trust us, the long-term payoff is well worth the initial effort. Calculate your savings with solar shingles here.

Efficiency and Power Output: Solar Shingles vs. Solar Panels

When it comes to solar shingles vs. solar panels, which is the better choice in terms of efficiency and power output? Let me break it down for you.

Powering homes and businesses, solar panels and solar shingles don’t just sit idly by as they work hard to convert sunlight into usable electricity.  With distinct differences in design and execution, it’s essential to understand how these differences impact their effectiveness. 

Factors Affecting Solar Shingle Efficiency

Solar shingle efficiency can be affected by a few things, like the quality of the photovoltaic cells, the shingle design, and how much direct sunlight they get.

Since solar roof shingles are installed flush against the roof, they may not always be angled optimally to capture maximum sun exposure. This can reduce their efficiency compared to rack-mounted solar panels. It is important to have them installed by a professional that can ensure the maximum efficiency of gathering energy for your home.

Factors Affecting Solar Panel Efficiency

Panel efficiency is influenced by the photovoltaic cell quality, panel design, and the amount of sunlight they receive. Panels can often be installed at the perfect angle for catching those powerful sun rays, which boosts their electricity generation.

Comparing Power Output

Because of their higher efficiency ratings, solar panels usually have a greater power output than solar shingles. An average solar panel system will produce more watts of energy per square foot of roof space.

However, the total power output you get really depends on the size of your solar array, the quality of the components, and how much sunlight hits your roof. So while solar panels may win on efficiency, solar shingles can still generate plenty of clean energy for your home.

Durability and Lifespan: Solar Shingles vs. Solar Panels

No one wants to invest in a solar roof that won’t withstand the passage of time, making durability a crucial factor to consider when deciding between solar shingles and solar panels.

Both options are built to be sturdy, but there are some differences in how they hold up against the elements. Let’s take a closer look at solar shingles vs. solar panels when it comes to durability and lifespan.

Durability of Solar Shingles

Solar shingles are engineered to outlast traditional asphalt roof shingles, constructed with tempered glass that resists impact, resounds with heavy rainfall, and bravely faces hail. When the going gets tough, these shingles really get going, effectively guarding your home from Mother Nature’s fury.

Since solar shingles are part of your roof itself, they’re less susceptible to damage from debris or high winds compared to rack-mounted solar panels. Many solar shingles are rated for winds up to 130 mph.

Durability of Solar Panels

Solar panels are constructed to withstand tough weather conditions.  Built to cope with hail the size of golf balls and carry the weight of heavy snow, they also flexibly adjust to wild temperature fluctuations. 

Premium solar panels use durable tempered glass and strong aluminum frames to protect against the harsh outdoor elements.  Many panel manufacturers offer robust 25-year warranties to back up their long-term resilience. With solar panels, you will need to periodically clean debris and wildlife, such as birds’ nests, out from under your panels to ensure they remain intact.

Expected Lifespan of Solar Shingles and Solar Panels

In terms of lifespan, both solar shingles and panels are built to last for decades. Most systems are warrantied for 25-30 years, but can keep generating power even longer.

Solar shingles have the advantage of being a 2-in-1 product – you get a durable new roof along with solar energy. So while the upfront cost may be higher, you could save money in the long run by avoiding a separate roof replacement.

Aesthetics and Curb Appeal: Solar Shingles vs. Solar Panels

One of the biggest selling points of solar shingles is their sleek, low-profile look. If you’re concerned about bulky panels affecting your home’s aesthetic, solar shingles are definitely worth considering.

Alluring and charming exteriors require thoughtfully selected roofing elements, such as solar shingles and panels.  Paying attention to the visual aspects of your home’s rooftop can elevate its appeal and create a stunning impression.  

A prime advantage of solar shingles is their stunning similarity to traditional roofing materials, resembling both asphalt shingles and slate tiles in terms of shape and appearance.

From the street, it’s hard to tell that a solar shingle roof is any different from a standard roof. The solar cells are often hidden, with only a slight sheen hinting at their true nature. This discreet look is a big plus for many homeowners.

Appearance of Solar Panels

In contrast, solar panels are more noticeable on a roof. They sit a few inches above the shingles and have a distinctive rectangular shape. While black monocrystalline panels are sleeker than blue polycrystalline ones, they’re still easy to spot.

Some people don’t mind the look of solar panels and even see them as a badge of their eco-friendly choices. But if you prefer a more traditional roofline, panels may not be the best fit, especially on a highly visible street-facing roof.

Impact on Home Value

Whichever option you choose, going solar can increase your property value. A study by Zillow found that homes with solar panels sell for 4.1% more on average than non-solar homes.

Solar shingles may offer an extra boost, since they enhance the look of the roof itself. A solar shingle roof can be a big selling point, with some buyers drawn to the combo of renewable energy and premium roofing material.

Which Is the Better Choice: Solar Shingles or Solar Panels?

Sometimes, deciding between solar shingles and traditional solar panels can be a dilemma. Weighing your options carefully will depend on your unique situation and priorities.

Factors to Consider When Making Your Decision

Here are some of the key things to think about when weighing solar shingles vs. solar panels:

• Your budget: Solar shingles have a higher upfront cost, while solar panels are more affordable.
• Your roof: Solar shingles are best for new construction or when you need a roof replacement anyway.
• Efficiency: Solar panels have higher efficiency ratings and power output.
• Aesthetics: Solar shingles offer a sleeker, more integrated look.
• Durability: Both options are designed to withstand the elements, but solar shingles may fare better in extreme weather.

If you’re exploring solar energy options, be sure to request quotes from multiple companies. Getting a few different estimates will allow you to size up the competition and find the best deal. Many solar companies will happily provide free quotes, so don’t be afraid to ask. Many companies also offer financing options to help with the upfront costs and allow you to pay for it over time.

Scenarios Where Solar Shingles Are the Better Choice

Solar shingles are a great fit if you’re building a new home or planning to replace your roof in the next few years. You can roll the cost of solar into your construction or roof replacement budget.

If you have a homeowners association with strict rules about roof appearance, solar shingles can help you go solar without violating any HOA guidelines. And if aesthetics are a top priority, solar shingles offer a discreet, upscale look.

Scenarios Where Solar Panels Are the Better Choice

Truth is, solar panels can save you a pretty penny in the long run. They’re often the better choice if you’re looking to make a smart financial move. Per square foot, they produce more power and cost less than shingles.

Sure, integrating solar shingles requires a bigger effort. But if your roof is still in good shape and you’re not planning a replacement anytime soon, solar panels are a simpler way to go. They can even be installed on flat roofs and certain metal roofing.

At the end of the day, both solar shingles and solar panels are a smart investment in clean energy. By weighing the pros and cons and considering your own needs and budget, you can find the solar solution that’s the perfect fit for your home.

FAQs in Relation to Solar Shingles Vs. Solar Panels: Which is the Better Choice?

What’s better, solar panels or solar shingles?

Solar shingles are like the luxury cars of the solar world: they’re sleek, high-end, and integrated into your roof.  Solar panels are like reliable sedans: efficient, cost-effective, and do the job.  Choose solar shingles for a seamless, aesthetics-focused approach or traditional solar panels for a more affordable, high-performing option. 

What are the drawbacks of solar shingles?

Solar shingles are still a newer technology, so they come with a higher price tag and limitations on roof types (no flat roofs, please).  Installation can be tricky, and finding certified installers might be a challenge.  Consider traditional solar panels for a more straightforward, cost-effective option. 

How long do solar shingles last?

Solar shingles can last up to 30 years or more, similar to traditional asphalt shingles. They’re built to withstand the elements and generate clean energy for years to come. Durability varies by manufacturer, so choose a reputable brand for a long-lasting, worry-free solar roof.

How much more expensive are solar shingles?

Solar shingles can cost 2-3 times more than traditional solar panels, making them a luxury option. However, they integrate seamlessly into your roof, eliminating the need for separate roofing materials. Calculate the total cost of ownership, including tax credits and long-term savings, to weigh the value of this premium option.

Conclusion

Deciding between solar shingles vs. solar panels ultimately comes down to your unique situation and priorities. If you’re planning to replace your roof anyway and want a sleek, integrated look, solar shingles could be the way to go. But if you’re looking for the most cost-effective and efficient option, traditional solar panels might be the better choice.

No matter which route you choose, both solar shingles and solar panels offer a fantastic opportunity to reduce your carbon footprint and save money on your energy bills in the long run. By harnessing the power of the sun, you can feel good about doing your part for the environment while also enjoying the benefits of clean, renewable energy.

If solar energy is on your mind, but you’re still unsure about the best approach, consider seeking the expertise of a reputable solar installation company. Their professionals will assess your home’s solar needs, address your questions, and offer bespoke recommendations to help you make an educated decision.

Mainstream consciousness has shifted towards sustainability, making solar energy a desirable option for environmentally aware individuals.  Whether opting for solar shingles or traditional solar panels, individuals can confidently align themselves with a greener future, benefitting both their wallet and the planet. 

Need help deciding which option is best for you? Get a FREE assessment here.